Superstar Stock Market: The Curious Case of Bray Wyatt | Smark Out Moment

Superstar Stock Market: The Curious Case of Bray Wyatt

Posted by Callum Wiggins Wednesday, September 17, 2014
WWE-roster-power-rankings-wrestlers-worthWelcome to the latest installment of Superstar Stock Market, where your friends at Smark Out Moment offer their years of expertise to discern how current WWE superstars are trending. Based on detailed analysis of their championship aspirations, gimmick potential, win/loss record and recent performances, we will offer specialist analysis on which superstars are worthy of investing time in, and which will have their backers in the midst of a Great Depression.

This edition concerns the monstrous Bray Wyatt—the self-professed Eater of Worlds. Wyatt certainly has made an instant impression on WWE since debuting in the summer of 2013, both through his spine-chilling psychology and emphatic promo skills. However, in recent months, his immediate momentum and originality has curtailed, and crowds have begun to wane on both him and his cult family. So, is Wyatt a future world champion in-the-making, or is he at risk of being eaten by the WWE Universe and expelled as an unfortunate experiment?

Value at end of previous year (12/31/2013)

Bray won't get anywhere in life constantly
looking backwards
Few superstars' stock was higher at the end of 2013 as Bray Wyatt. In spite of an awful debut performance against Kane at SummerSlam, his creepy promos caught the imagination of the crowd instantaneously. Alongside his imposing henchmen Luke Harper and Erick Rowan, Wyatt took the stance of a puppet master, rarely wrestling, but always around to take a cheap shot and destroy any individual he takes a disliking to.

After hurriedly disposing of Kofi Kingston, Wyatt's stock rose dramatically by engaging with fan favorites CM Punk and Daniel Bryan. The verbal and physical battles opposite such high profile names indicated to fans that Wyatt was going to be a big deal, and he maintained an unbeaten record to hammer home the point. A 3-on-1 handicap match against Bryan at TL was an utter destruction job, and on the final RAW of 2013, the beatings he sustained convinced the beloved goat-face to surrender and join the Family. This left Wyatt with an incredible amount of momentum, and he was one of the most compelling parts of WWE by the turn of the year.

2014 Win/Loss Record

Win – 27
Loss – 22
Draw/No Contest – 0

Royal Rumble Win (vs. Daniel Bryan)
Elimination Chamber Win (vs. The Shield)
WrestleMania Loss (vs. John Cena)
Extreme Rules Win (vs. John Cena)
Payback Loss (vs. John Cena)
Money in the Bank Loss (WWE World Heavyweight Championship Money in the Bank Match)
Battleground Loss (vs. Chris Jericho)
SummerSlam Win (vs. Chris Jericho)

Gimmick potential

That is a fetching fedora Mr. Wyatt
Wyatt's gimmick is undoubtedly unique in the world of professional wrestling. He portrays a megalomaniacal cult leader, who hates everything about the world and wishes to inflict that pain onto others. He understands that he is different and deranged, but that has allowed him to see the world as it truly his. Wyatt and those that follow him do not live in the ignorance that life is built around happiness and opportunity, but suffering and devastation, and in that world he is a God among men. His catchphrase 'Follow the Buzzards' is indicative of the birds' preying on the decaying corpses of fallen souls.

Wyatt's look is also undoubtedly inimitable in wrestling, yet has drawn comparisons Max Cady in Cape Fear. Wearing a fedora and patterned shirts demonstrate his connection to the bayous of Florida. The beard and hair is both magnificent and ominous, and adds to his aura of dominance. Every detail from sitting in a rocking chair as a vindictive puppet-master to his ring entrance is fundamental in constructing his distinctive persona.

Nevertheless, as time has worn on, it appears the WWE creative team have failed to keep up with Wyatt's infamy among the audience. Whilst his promo skills are impeccable at best, in the last few months he has been using that silver tongue to spout incomprehensible drivel. His most recent feud with Chris Jericho has demonstrated that without a great deal of thought, his broad vocabulary can become as empty as his black heart. Perhaps the writing team cannot keep up with a character as complex and cryptic as The Man of 1,000 Truths?

Signature Moves and Ringwork

This is unquestionably the most contentious element of Wyatt's role within the WWE. Never in my decade of devotion to professional wrestling have I witnessed such an offbeat ring style. It has elements of established monster heels comparable to Kane or an early Mankind, but with a capacity for explosive attacks remarkable for a man his size, similar to an in-shape Samoa Joe. Wyatt's style is reliant on psychological warfare, arguably the most difficult skill for a superstar to learn. This likely is a benefit of his upbringing as a third-generation superstar. Sister Abigail is also a quick and effective finisher, with the additional theatrics building into his character.

Yet, it is remarkable how hit-and-miss this methodical ring style has proven to be in his year in WWE. Wyatt has been capable of outstanding matches with the right superstars, but consistency in this regard has been non-existent. Opposite Daniel Bryan and the Shield he looked tremendous, whilst against Kane and The Big Show he has been met with deafening silence. More bafflingly, in matches against John Cena and Chris Jericho, we have witnessed both sides of the wrestling Wyatt.

Is he being carried by wrestlers that can put on a good match with anyone? As the saying goes, it takes two to tango, and Wyatt's mannerisms and powerful repertoire certainly have their appeal. But, many have noted the consistent performances of Harper and Rowan have been overshadowing their overseer. If Wyatt is to reach his fullest potential, he has to begin making a habit of performing at his best.

Championship Aspirations

Bray likes his chances at the gold - do you?
Wyatt has been for the most part kept away from the championship scene altogether. His brethren have been eternally pursuing the WWE Tag Team Championships, but the master has been stoic as far as a title run is concerned. His one world title match was in the Money in the Bank ladder match which was won by former nemesis John Cena. Wyatt had a strong performance, but never looked as though he was legitimately going to win the belt.

Wyatt doesn't need championships to maintain legitimacy. His motivations do not entail the hungry pursuit of gold, but the need for other to recognise and feel his horrific vision of the world. However, a run with the WWE Heavyweight Championship could be driven from his desire to spread his monstrous message and expand his following through acquisition of the industry's biggest prize. Current plans for him to pursue the Intercontinental Championship instead reek of an attempt to recover his floundering reputation from months of indifference and poor booking. It might work, but it certainly doesn't carry the same presence.

Highest Peak – 26th January 2014 (Royal Rumble)

Wyatt has had a number of awesome matches and promos in his short time in WWE. His feud with John Cena left him with too many defeats, but a number of memorable depictions of Cena's negative reception and the fallibilities of his heroic stature. It also provided a fantastically brutal Last Man Standing match at Over the Limit. But, his most impressive feud was opposite his fellow bearded grappler Daniel Bryan, and their match at Royal Rumble was the perfect demonstration of his monstrous power, in-ring psychology and ominous presence.

Lowest Valley – 20th July 2014 (Battleground)

The feud against John Cena produced some great moments, but Wyatt ended up on the losing side when the dust had settled. But, a loss against someone as heavily pushed as Cena often is can be recovered over time, despite the damage it did to his dominant run. Compounding it with a loss to a returning Chris Jericho however was utterly nonsensical. In their disappointing feud, if Jericho was to win a match it should have been on an episode of RAW with a quick roll-up. Having him hit a single Codebreaker for the victory severely damaged Wyatt's credibility as a destroyer. Add that to the overall terrible build and match itself, and this was an unprecedented low for the entire Wyatt Family.

Peaks Valleys
Attacking Kane on debut Ring of Fire match against Kane at SummerSlam 2013
Forcing Daniel Bryan to join the Wyatt
Losses against Cena
at WrestleMania and Over the Limit
Victory over Bryan at Royal Rumble Steel cage match with Cena
at Extreme Rules
Beating down John Cena
at end of Royal Rumble
Matches against the Big Show on any card
Tag team bouts against the Shield Entire feud against Chris Jericho besides
final encounter
Promos building to Cena
match at Wrestlemania
Manhandled by Cena
on a RAW following SummerSlam
Performance in Last Man Standing match at
Over the Limit

Steel cage victory over Chris Jericho on


• Promo Skills
• Creepy, unique look and gimmick
• Big man power with explosive speed
• Feuds with top superstars
• Crowd reaction
• Luke Harper and Erick Rowan


• Too many big losses damaging mystique
• Lack of comprehension/direction to what he is saying
• Inconsistent in-ring performances
• Too slow/methodical often

Stock Advisement – BUY CAUTIOUSLY

This is regarded as a curious case of stock for a reason, as Wyatt is an enigma capable of ascendancy or decline. He is a powerful competitor that is also remarkably quick, but his methodical pacing could indicate his low stamina and inability to have great extended matches on a regular basis. Many suggest he is being carried by better wrestlers, and he has yet to fully prove them wrong. Wyatt is certainly capable of fantastic matches and telling captivating stories in the ring, but he does not do it consistently enough to merit a huge rise up the roster.

Wyatt is a confirmed lower main event talent through the calibre of those he has feuded with thus far, but is certainly far from a world championship run as things stand. And who'd really be overly impressed with an Intercontinental title reign in this day and age? His feuds need more direction, and he needs to be booked as a pure monster again after a string of lacklustre feuds that have left him looking weaker by the day.

The two saving graces for Wyatt are the uniquely ominous nature of his gimmick that is his and his alone, and how much he has bought into the character. The earnestness in which he delivers his promos with a mixture of vulnerable anguish and tyrannical vigour should be applauded, as no matter what he says it carries a reaction or meaning. Hopefully the writing team can catch up with him in order to give him opportunity to focus more on his in-ring prowess then questioning why he is saying what he is saying. For now, Wyatt is both young and distinctive enough to secure a sustained main event run in the near future.

Just a word of caution though; this relies on WWE writers and bookers being competent and pragmatic… Follow the buzzards.

Bray is coming for you Creative Team...
Chances of Stock Rising – 70%


Subscribe to Smack Talk on iTunes and Stitcher

Callum Wiggins hails from Essex in the United Kingdom. He recently graduated from the University of York with a degree in History and has been a fan of professional wrestling since 2002. Outside of wrestling, he is also a fan of Arsenal FC and enjoys video games, darts, and Formula One. You can follow him on Facebook, Twitter and Google+.


Current EVENTS

Watch Mae Young Classic 2018 PPV Live Results

WWE Mae Young Classic 2018 Predictions and Results

Watch Super Show-Down 2018 PPV Live Results

WWE Super Show-Down PPV Predictions and Results

Watch Evolution 2018 PPV Live Results

WWE Evolution 2018 PPV Predictions and Results

Watch Crown Jewel 2018 PPV Live Results

WWE Crown Jewel 2018 PPV Predictions and Results


If you would like to join the Smark Out Moment writing team, please send an email via the contact form.

Follow Us

Subscribe to Smack Talk on iTunes and Stitcher





Follow by Email